Binding :DVD
ProductGroup :DVD
EAN :9780000143587
Lowest Price :$49.99USD
The perceptions of the opera did most of the damage, I believe. In Richard Taruskins revealing essay of Tchaikovsky in Grove, Cesar Cui noted that Tchaikovsky identified with the Joan dArc too profoundly, as if giving her a sense of divinity. Theres a certain truth to that, though not very surprising. Like Massenet, Tchaikovskys gift rested in his understanding of the characters, sometimes to the point of becoming one of them. In reviewing his Manfred Symphony under Pletnev, Ive noted the composers relation to the anger, tormentation, soul searching, and redemption and inner peace Manfred underwent. That was Tchaikovskys life in a nutshell. Tchaikovsky did not become Joan d Arc, but a recent breakdown of his marriage played a role in his treatment of the opera.
Did Tchaikovsky damaged Joan d Arcs mission in the eyes of heaven? No, Tchaikovsky was too good of a musical psychologist for that. He, however, added human dimensions to Joan dArc beyond the divinity and gave her inner strength and even a sense of vulnerabilty that are compelling. The work is to an extant a grand opera for the rhetoric leans towards Meyerbeer while the sense of urgency in some pages suggests his familiarity with Verdi. But out of Verdi and Meyerbeer, Rubinstein was the bigger influence. For example, in the middle of Act I (the chorus of the Maidens), the opera inherits the nobleness and the old-mannered dignity to be found in Rubinsteins "The Demon." But Tchaikovsky was his own man, with his orchestration and choral writing idiomatic, glorious and even poetic. The end of Act I for example, with Jeanne d Arcs aria accompaning by the Chorus of the Maidens, shows Tchaikovsky as among his best.
Tchaikovskys treatment of the rest of the cast is also very compelling and singers of the Kirov Opera and Ballet met the challenges euphoniously. V. Kilchevsky as Charles VII was strong and commanding throughout. But Sofya Preobrazhenskaya, a brilliant yet overlooked soprano, made a name of herself particularly by performing Jeanne dArc throughout her career. She gave the character a sort of femininity that is strong, willful, and convicted, as if guided by God himself. But Preobrazhenskaya avoided the one-dimensionalism of the character that could have been easily undertaken by those not so familiar with the role as she was (except Irina Arkhipova in a later Melodiya recording). She made Jeanne d Arc a vulnerable, pure human being, torn between her divine mission and her love for Lionel (passionately sung by L. Solomyak). The love duet between them in Act IV is especially spellbinding before Jeannes execution.
Boris Khaikin was an excellent concert and theatrical conductor of the former Soviet Russia. He led the Chorus and Orchestra of the Kirov Opera and Ballet Theatre with fiery temperament and drive. Yet there are places where he can have this magical sense of subtlety and vividness. Its unfortunate that he, like so many conductors around his generation (such as Samosud, Melik-Pashayev, and Nebolsin), remained so little known. The original 1946 recording is well captured on these dics and the fillers (esp. of Mussorgskys Khovanschina) are further incentives to purchase this CD album. The presentation is relatively disappointing, though, with no libretto, inadequate history behind the work, and no slip case. But the performance itself is truly in a demonstration class.
However as a tie-in with the current production on Broadway, I can see no artistic purpose. My 3 stars are for the beauty of the music and the quality of the performances. And perhaps someone actually will take up the idea of committing the entire play to discs or better still to videos. Now that would be a real tie-in!